Wednesday, January 13, 2010

Craziness at New Philadelphia City Hall

Prosecutor Ryan Styer has determined that New Philadelphia Income Tax Administrator Dixie Dyer committed no crime after he, the Bureau of Criminal Identification and Investigation and the New Philadelphia Police Department investigated allegations that Ms. Dyer wasn't working enough.

That's right -- a management issue turned into a criminal investigation, wasting taxpayer dollars and investigator manhours.

The whole thing, reported in The Times-Reporter, is just craziness.

Dyer answers to New Philadelphia Auditor Beth Gundy, who ultimately said Dyer is doing the job she was hired to do. If I'm reading correctly, why didn't the police -- if they were the first to receive the complaint from what appears to be disgruntled and/or jealous employees -- go to Gundy in the first place?

Why didn't the employees go to Gundy? Or the mayor?

Why did BCI get involved in a city of New Philadelphia management issue?

Why did the county prosecutor get involved in a city of New Philadelphia management issue?

For goodness sakes, it's New Philadelphia, not bureaucracy-laden, corruption-loving Cuyahoga County. Are the inmates running the asylum in New Philadelphia? Hello, is anybody in charge?

If Dyer's work ethic is an issue then it's one voters can take up with Auditor Gundy at the appropriate time. If I were on City Council, I might be asking questions how a management issue ultimately ended up on the desk of the county prosecutor via a state police agency.

Then I would apologize to Ms. Dyer.

* * *
See you next time.


Melvin said...

"When she works more than 40 hours a week, she said that converts to compensatory time, which she uses along with her five weeks of earned vacation."

That's the last sentence in the TR story. I've worked as a salaried person for 35+ years. Never had comp time. The down side to being salaried is you get paid the same, regardless of how much you work beyond 40 hours a week. The up side is that, even if you work less, you still get paid the same. Since you're not punching a time clock you are evaluated on getting the job done...not long long it takes.

I'm not sure that added more time to an already generous five weeks of vacation time per year is appropriate for a salaried person. Is that standards in NP City Hall for other salaried people?

Anonymous said...


At one point you asked for an example of something going right somewhere in Ohio. We know it's not in the public sector, but there's a pretty good story coming out of SUPERB Industries at Sugarcreek and it's starting to gain traction. This may not be what you're looking for, but it's worth a read. You taught me a few things. Thanks.

Here's a link to the press kit I put together for SUPERB